Comments, opinions and an occasional ramble
Hijacking a country
What the People’s Alliance for Democracy (PAD) did in Bangkok last week was simply appalling, even by my liberal standards of democracy and human rights. I am all for freedom of speech and even civil disobedience, provided the situation warrants it, but to take a country hostage by seizing airports and disrupting the lives of millions of other people needlessly is simply inexcusable.
To me, the PAD is like the bands of Somali pirates that hijack ships, or even the group of terrorists that attacked Mumbai. Of course, the parallels might appear extreme to some. After all, the PAD didn’t seek to kill anyone or create massive chaos. However, by virtue of their actions, the PAD has effectively disrupted the livelihoods of millions of other Thais, and if you are a poor Thai who depends on tourirst dollars to survive, you are basically handed a slow death. The PAD didn’t take away lives directly but I think the torment inflicted on many Thais in terms of earning a livelihood is going to last a while, and I don’t think that is much better than what Mumbai suffered.
Putting aside my rants, this episode demonstrates to me the pitfalls of a democracy that is unable to check itself. For a week, I was actually a little grateful living in a country with draconian laws on assembly. At the very least, Changi Airport isn’t going to get hijacked by a bunch of people seeking to force their wills on others. I still dislike the restrictions placed on demonstrations in Singapore, despite the relaxation on rules this year, but at least for now, I appreciate the necessity of regulating protests and demonstration to avoid such political hijacking.
I think the political liberal in me has taken a small step to the right.
| Print article | This entry was posted by Aaron Ng on 04/12/2008 at 1:35 pm, and is filed under Perspective. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback from your own site. |


about 3 years ago
Hi Aaron,
I think that political intelligence and maturity of the electorate is a fascinating subject.
How can it be measured? How much is enough for a stable liberal democracy? Does it even matter? I think that these are very important but infrequently-asked questions. It would be great to do some research on this topic and write an essay on it, and I’m thinking of doing so soon.
Thanks!
about 3 years ago
Hi Aaron
On the surface, it looks like democracy gone bonkers, but actually it is a chess game played at the highest levels by the powers that be.
This power ( which cannot be named and cannot be criticized) and its proxies are using the people as pawns to advance its agenda.
Whatever it is, Thailand is the loser and by default its competitors in tourism ( including medical tourism) gain.
I get patients from the region who use to go to Bumrumgrad Hospital coming to see me for treatment. I am sure this trend will continue if the Thais cannot get their act together. It will be deja vu after the next elections and the next.
PAD’s acronyn ( People’s Alliance for Democracy) is ironic as this is the most undemocratic bunch of people there is.
Yes I also agree with you that after this example of “demonstration without limits” our Hong Lim Park looks like a neater way of having free expressions. It is boring but who needs the type of excitement at the Thai airports.
So when you moved to the right, did you also notice me following just behind you?
It is tough being a liberal nowadays.
Dr. Huang
about 3 years ago
Michael,
Good point, although I’m thinking it’s very difficult to design a study on the topic. Probably won’t get conclusive answers.
about 3 years ago
Dr Huang,
Out of respect, I’ve refrained from commenting about the Thai king. A benevolent king would have spoken out against the the actions of the PAD.
And, the biggest threat to being a political liberal is terrorism. It’s damn hard to be a liberal when these terrorists just comes in and disrupt lives. It’s sad, but welcome to the shift to the right.
about 3 years ago
democracy in thailand is royally screwed.
about 3 years ago
PAD basically is a “Puppet Administered by Dictate” of the Powerful-Almighty-Dictator backed by the Army and the Elites who were in power before Thaksin was popularly elected and chosen by the commoners and the poor to represent them to give the Almighty Dictator a run for his money.
So much so, now Thaksin is seen as trying to build a Republic to overthrow the Monarch, and his life is now in danger. That was why he went exile again.
Basically, therefore, PAD can do anything it likes because the Almighty Emperor allows it to do so. PERIOD.
Similarly, at the home ground, PAP can do whatever it likes because the Almighty Emperor wants it to be so.
Wan Sui Wan Sui, Wan Wan Sui,
Welcome to the Kingdom of the RIGHT Red Dot.
about 3 years ago
Dear Aaron,
I urge you not to lose faith in liberal democracy. In Thailand’s case, the People’s Alliance for Democracy (most anti-democratic forces in history usually include “democratic” in their names in an ironic fashion) is actually a political pawn which the Bangkok elite mobilized to sabotage democracy. It is not democracy that failed, but the failure of the elite to accept a democratically-elected government that was legitimately elected by the people of Thailand. The army, the bureaucracy, the aristocrats and the conservatives are afraid to lose their political influence. It is not absolute power that corrupts, but it is the fear of losing power that corrupts.
Democracy is about learning and growing. It is a process as much as it is an idea. Yet, the Bangkok elite’s aim is to reverse the political awakening of the lower classes in Thai society. The main problem in Thailand is not democracy. It is the absence of the rule of law. You can have chaos anywhere, even in authoritarian systems, if there is no rule of law. Look at how the Constitutional Court disband the PPP. Putting politics aside, the ruling is a judicial joke. It is so obvious that there is no proper legal procedure.
I remembered some Taiwanese complaining how messy the politics on the island have gotten ever since democratization in the 1990s. But when asked whether they want to return to the 38 years of martial law regime under the one party state presided by the KMT, they answered, “Hell, no.”
Moving on to the point on terrorism, i think you should look at things from another angle. Terrorism’s aim is to disrupt society’s way of life. If you succumb to their manipulations and start having doubts about your democratic ideals, then terrorism has achieved its objectives.
about 3 years ago
ad,
I can see your point and I’m not exactly losing faith in liberal democracy. It is still a cherished ideal of mine but the reality is that it can be easily manipulated without proper checks and balances, and that really scares me. And you’re right about terrorism. Thanks for the reminder.
about 3 years ago
Aaron,
what is happening in Thailand is not democracy going wrong, but people seeking to destroy democracy for their own ends, and in the process hoodwinking a whole bunch of people. It also appears that the law is being subverted (see the speedy disposition of cases relating to Thaksin and the relative laxness with which the PAD ring leaders were treated by the courts). I think this article summarises the situation rather nicely.
http://www.economist.com/world/asia/displaystory.cfm?story_id=12724800
about 3 years ago
i heard the thai protestors are pay few hundered dollars a day by…….
about 3 years ago
Aaron
Welcome to reality.
I gave up on liberal politics in general but not in specific as it is highly noticeable that the so called liberal elites do not practice in the main what they preach to the masses.
Regards
about 3 years ago
Your article is very interesting, i bookmarked your blog for future referrence
about 2 years ago
interesting blog, bookmarked for the future referrence, what template do you use ?
about 4 months ago
It was a real contentment getting to your site this morning. I arrived here today hoping to uncover interesting things. I was not let down. Your ideas about new techniques on this area were enlightening and a great help to myself. Thank you for creating time to write down these things and for sharing your notions.
about 4 months ago
Many thanks for your time and effort to have decided to put these things together on this website. Janet and I very much treasured your ideas through the articles with certain things. I realize that you have a number of demands in your program so the fact that you took all the time like you did to help people like us by this article is actually highly loved.
about 4 months ago
It was a pleasure discovering your site this morning. I arrived here just now hoping to come across something new. I was not disappointed. Your ideas upon new tactics on this subject matter were enlightening and an excellent help to myself. Thank you for making time to write out these things plus for sharing your ideas.
about 3 months ago
What would all of us do without the presence of the awesome concepts you discuss on this web site? Who else has got the tolerance to deal with vital topics in the interest of common visitors like me? I and my buddies are very blessed to have your website among the ones we generally visit. It is hoped you know how much we take pleasure in your working hard! Best wishes from us all.
about 3 months ago
I won’t be able to thank you adequately for the posts on your web site. I know you placed a lot of time and energy into them and hope you know how deeply I appreciate it. I hope I’m able to do the same for another person one of these days.