Comments, opinions and an occasional ramble
Interesting news report
The Home section of the Straits Times today had a story on the first page of the section (after the Kaplan advertisement) titled “Ex-MP may be charged for not disclosing business stake”.
The editors clearly think that it’s an important story, thus putting it on the front page. However, when I read the report, there was absolutely NO mention of who the MP was. The report merely listed the business interests of the person, as well as saying that the ex-MP served four terms of parliament.
This is really interesting because I don’t see a reason why the ex-MP should not be named. I can understand that people cannot be named if the case is still under police investigation. However, the article never mentioned that. So, why the secrecy over the name of the ex-MP? The few exceptions I can accept for not publishing names are cases like rape, child molest etc because it’s bad enough that the victims suffered such grief against their will, and the last thing that they need is more spotlight on their grief.
What I don’t understand is why a four term ex-MP cannot be named. Chances are, the ex-MP was a member of the PAP. I cannot help but wonder if that is the reason why ST did not publish the name of the ex-MP. And, considering that it’s a four term MP, that person must be pretty high-profile. Perhaps it’s a bad time to disclose names given the current public unhappiness with the PAP dominated government.
Whatever the reason, I don’t think it’s good journalistic practice. A first-class country without a first-class newspaper.
| Print article | This entry was posted by Aaron Ng on 20/04/2007 at 2:22 pm, and is filed under Perspective. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback from your own site. |


about 6 years ago
What do you mean by “chances” Aaron? There is no non-PAP ex-MP that has served 4 terms!
about 6 years ago
The MP is probably not name because he was an opposition MP so the Straits Times does not want to be accused of running down the opposition. I’m sure if the MP was a PAP MP, he will be name for the sake of transparency and accountability.
about 6 years ago
The ex MP may be charged for not disclosing business stake….its either he is not aware that he needs to disclose his business stake or that he is aware but choose to be dishonest and kay seow….
But to serve 4 terms and still not aware…who would believe….this just shows that high salary does not breed honesty, integrity etc etc…
btw, have you consider translating whatever you wrote in your english blog into your chinese blog?
about 6 years ago
Ethical journalists who are compelled to withhold the identity of a person in a news story should include a statement explaining WHY the identity is withheld. That would include the publication’s policy on not revealing the identity of rape victims. So, my first reaction to the ST withholding this person’s identity without explanation was that the person in question must be a member of the PAP. Any chance at all that the ST would withhold the identity if the person had been in an opposition party?
about 6 years ago
yaz… i noticed that too… and the weirdest thing is… the name is revealed in the channelnewsasia website (http://www.channelnewsasia.com/stories/singaporelocalnews/view/271473/1/.html)…
hMm… what are those people thinking of?
about 6 years ago
by right, a newspaper must give a reason for not revealing the name. maybe it’s “against public interest” haha.
i get a feeling the government might have known of this long time ago. but that’s only too cynical of me. but the effect of delaying a case for someone who’s no longer “one of them” is lessened. i mean, look at the yeo cheow tong issue. it’s all about timing, isn’t it?
then again, SPH’s press time is 1am today, while the CNA website published the article at 2pm. so maybe it’s just new news.
about 6 years ago
Sam,
I’m very sure ST knew of the identity of the MP. If ST was not sure if the story was true, they wouldn’t have even ran the story in the first place because it would mean being sued in court.
That aside, I’m glad CNA reported the name of the person. So it’s Chng Hee Kok, the guy who got into a tussle with Philip Yeo over the issue of scholarships some years back (and coincidentally did not continue onto a 5th term after that episode).
about 6 years ago
Linda,
I am very sure if it’s an opposition party member, the name would have been revealed instantly!
about 6 years ago
Shanghai-hood,
I will do translations from time to time, depending on whether I think it’s important to repeat the content on both blogs. I don’t intend to make both carbon copies of one another, but if it’s something worth writing about, I will make sure it’s available in both languages.
Of course, another consideration would be whether I think I’m proficient enough to translate. There are some terms and names that I might not be able to translate correctly, so I might avoid it altogether.
about 6 years ago
Craftsman,
I was trying to be polite.
about 6 years ago
Fella,
ST is an oddball sometimes. I think that CNA has more gall than ST regarding such news, although there were instances where you see different versions of news at different times of the day, such as the employment figures of foreigners. That was a classic one. Three revisions in one day if I am not mistaken, and of course, readers were not told.
I believe that CNA operates on a “if no one complains, we’ll leave things as it is policy.”
about 6 years ago
Aaron
Actually no sinister or machiavellian motive here….Don’t you know that this teaser journalism is an old trick and a good way to maintain ( poor ST must have seen a declining circulation given its unobjective reporting all these years ) or boost readership?
about 6 years ago
CNA has an audience stretching Asia to the Middle East. And do keep in mind that the Gulf papers report on issues in Singapore from AP and Reuters’ feed as well, and not from the ST’s point of view.
To upkeep their credibility, I don’t think CNA can afford to operate with blinkers like the ST.
about 6 years ago
Dear Aaron,
It is all about timing. ST articles are prepared early so that the prints are out on the street in the early morning. So early that the courts have not opened the doors yet. ST may not want to preempt the court’s official announcements. CNA named the ex-MP after the courts read out the charges in the afternoon.
Then again, this timing of things can be used to a certain advantage.
about 6 years ago
Read the Chinese Night Newspaper last night, the face is shown at front page in full glory ! The full glory of PAP’s successful story in glooming leader who love money so much that it sell away his moral authority and instead develop his money authority !
But then, miniLee might say we have still very honest gov, because only MP who leave PAP will not no longer protected by Moral Authority of PAP and therefore be tempted into dark side outside PAP’s protection !!!!!
So guys, let’s join PAP if you want to have moral authority.
This highlight a simple problem, those ICAC people at least has some moral authority to have expose these exPAP after the salary hike !!!
Hurray to ICAC, now let see they check on other PAP’s members.
about 6 years ago
Dear boyying,
I would like to have ICAC (www.icac.org.hk) too, but alas, they are in Hong Kong. In Singapore, it is CPIB .
In Singapore, we get the moral authority of the PM looking over CPIB.
“The Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau (CPIB) is an independent body which investigates and aims to prevent corruption in the public and private sectors in Singapore. Established in 1952, it derives its powers of investigation from the Prevention of Corruption Act (Chapter 241). The bureau is headed by a director who is directly responsible to the Prime Minister.“
link: http://www.cpib.gov.sg/aboutus.htm
Interesting to know that they have stopped winning awards since 2005, as seen on their home page. If one looks at their new building along Jalan Bukit Merah, their entrance faced away from the main road. Very interesting design.
about 6 years ago
Haha that’s very smart…there’s already a contradiction in their introduction. Independent but answerable to the PM? Maybe PAP does give moral authority…i.e., they define what’s moral and what’s not…well done to the ST for proving to us why they’re at the 140th!
about 6 years ago
No lah, he did this because he didn’t get the pay increment. if he did, he wouldn’t have done this at all. that is why the increase was so urgent.
about 6 years ago
Another Reader,
It is technically not wrong to release the name if the court schedule has already stated what will be going on the next day. It’s public information, if I am not mistaken. If eventually the charge was withdrawn, the story still stands because the original information was correct.
about 6 years ago
Another Reader ,
thank for correcting,
Now I understand why PM was never convicted of corruption when during last election PM say he need to buy supporter vote (using tax money!) and fix opposition party because CPIB bureau is headed by a director who is directly responsible to the Prime Minister !!! It is the prime minister paying CPIB out of tax-money.
It should be renamed as CIUPM (Corruption Investigation Under PM). That’s sound more credible. If it is opp Party who say what PM say, I sure that will be the last of opp party !!\\
So ic, it pay to be PM since everything, tom, dick and harry is under him. Then Singapore is doomed as its future depend on the moral authority of PM and its whities !!
CPIB is independent but answerable to PM. hmmm, if applies to NKF, it becomes ‘A non-profit charity organisation answerable to its shareholders’. How’s about that ?
about 6 years ago
I visit the site
http://www.cpib.gov.sg/aboutus.htm
The website really look like cartoon and not professional.
about 6 years ago
My apology to digress a little for I think morality and virtues are void when conscience does not exist!
about 4 years ago
all nude angel angel art clip angel art angel nude africa
[URL=http://dfhtt.o-f.com/angel/angel1.html]all nude angel angel art clip angel art angel nude africa[/URL]
about 1 year ago
Hello There. I discovered your weblog the use of msn. This is a very well written article. I’ll be sure to bookmark it and come back to learn more of your useful info. Thank you for the post. I will definitely return.
about 1 year ago
I am unable to thank you fully for the blogposts on your website. I know you set a lot of time and energy into all of them and truly hope you know how much I appreciate it. I hope I will do the identical thing for someone else someday.
about 1 year ago
I simply wanted to inform you how much my partner and i appreciate almost everything you’ve contributed to help increase the value of the lives of an individual in this subject material. Through your articles, we’ve gone out of just a beginner to a skilled in the area. It can be truly a honor to your good work. Thanks
about 1 year ago
I just now wanted to inform you about how much I actually appreciate everything you’ve contributed to help enhance the lives of folks in this subject matter. Through the articles, we have gone from just an inexperienced to a pro in the area. It’s truly a homage to your endeavours. Thanks
about 1 year ago
Thanks a ton for your time and efforts to have decided to put these things together on this weblog. Emily and that i very much appreciated your suggestions through your articles on certain things. I understand that you have several demands with your program therefore the fact that you actually took equally as much time just like you did to steer people just like us via this article is actually highly prized.
about 1 year ago
It was some sort of excitement getting to your site yesterday. I came up here now hoping to come across new things. I was not let down. Your ideas with new tactics on this subject matter were helpful and a terrific help to myself. Thank you for leaving out time to write down these things as well as for sharing your mind.
about 1 year ago
I merely wanted to inform you about how much I actually appreciate almost everything you’ve contributed to help improve the lives of individuals in this subject matter. Through your articles, I’ve really gone via just an amateur to a pro in the area. It can be truly a tribute to your initiatives. Thanks
about 1 year ago
Hey:):)
about 1 year ago
What would most people do without the marvellous suggestions you share on this blog? Who has got the persistence to deal with vital topics with regard to common visitors like me? My partner and i and my guys are very blessed to have your blog among the types we often visit. Hopefully you know how a great deal we appreciate your work! Best wishes coming from us all.
about 1 year ago
I couldn’t currently have asked for an even better blog. You happen to be always at hand to give excellent guidance, going straight to the point for convenient understanding of your readership. You’re truly a terrific pro in this area. Thanks for always being there for folks like me.
about 1 year ago
What would we all do without the amazing ideas you discuss on this web site? Who comes with the endurance to deal with essential topics for the sake of common readers like me? My spouse and i and my pals are very lucky to have your blog among the types we generally visit. Hopefully you know how much we enjoy your efforts! Best wishes from us all.
about 1 year ago
Thanks a ton for your time and efforts to have had these things together on this website. Janet and that i very much treasured your input through the articles about certain things. I recognize that you have a variety of demands with your schedule therefore the fact that you actually took the maximum amount of time like you did to help people just like us through this article is even highly appreciated.
about 10 months ago
Heya i’m for the initial time here. I found this board and I to uncover It truly valuable & it helped me out a good deal. I hope to offer something back and aid other people such as you helped me.
about 5 months ago
Hi there, You’ve done a fantastic job. I’ll definitely digg it and personally recommend to my friends. I’m sure they’ll be benefited from this site.
about 1 month ago
Extraordinarily educative thanks, I believe your trusty readers could want even more information similar to this carry on the wonderful effort.