Comments, opinions and an occasional ramble
Tammy number 2 on porn cousin of YouTube?
Someone posted an irrelevant comment on my previous blog entry and it somehow got caught in my spam filter. I read the comment more closely and discovered the commenter posted several links to a site called YouPorn.com, and the links are to a lovemaking couple that the commenter claims to be “evidently Singaporean”.
There are two main issues to this matter. The first is a porn version of YouTube. It should come as no surprise to me as a student of new media that the porn cousin of YouTube has finally made its appearance. After all, it is well known that the most profitable online businesses belong to the pornography industry. The appearance of YouPorn (notice how the name is deliberately made similar to YouTube) brings about many implications.
The first of course is whether the porn industry is going to go bust now that free porn of pretty acceptable quality is available to anyone with an Internet browser. The second implication is that ease of accessibility to pornography to minors just went up another level. I do not object to pornography for adults, but I am concerned about young, impressionable kids who might be watching the videos in their own bedrooms without any form of guidance. The last implication, which coincides with the second issue I’m going to deal with, is the issue of ordinary folks uploading their own making out videos online.
I cannot verify whether the couple in the YouPorn video are indeed Singaporeans, although I am of the opinion that there’s a high probability. Assuming that the couple is indeed Singaporean, then we are looking at Tammy version 2.0. And the same old questions that were being asked during the Tammy saga will surface again, especially questions of morality. To what extent can we accept exhibitionism in Singapore?
I think YouPorn is going to be an interesting case for many countries in the world. YouTube has already caused quite a fair bit of problems in terms of copyright issues. YouPorn has the potential to cause not only copyright issues (with the pornography industry), but it will also cause moral panic. I’m going to wait and see how the issue of YouPorn will pan out across the world.
Note:
I am not re-posting the links to the video that was supplied by the original commenter because I am not sure if I will be contravening any Singapore law on pornography in doing so. Although I have a policy of allowing free speech, I’m not permitting any comment that contains links to the videos for the reason stated in the preceding sentence. I hope everyone understands that this is a grey area in terms of law.
| Print article | This entry was posted by Aaron Ng on 25/02/2007 at 4:48 am, and is filed under Perspective, Technology. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback from your own site. |


about 4 years ago
Ben apparently has the same comment left on his blog regarding Youporn. Read about it here:
http://1moresg.wordpress.com/2007/02/24/to-the-authorities/
about 4 years ago
There are more than 1 porn video sharing sites in the internet, fyi
about 4 years ago
Fair enough that there’s more than one. But YouPorn strikes me as standing out because it looks rather close to YouTube. To my knowledge, YouPorn has the least restrictions compared to the rest. Plus, the presence of more than 1 porn file upload/sharing sites doesn’t erase the concerns that I’ve highlighted.
about 4 years ago
Hmm. I think I am going to draw a lot of controversy/flak from saying this, but I don’t really see Youporn as a negative thing. Even though we do understand that there are no age restrictions on it, but then again, there have never been any real age restrictions on other porn sites either. A lot of people watch porn before they turn 18 or 21 anyway (although this doesn’t necessarily mean that all of them will have sex at a young age), so basically anyone who wants to watch it badly enough will find some way to, no matter what.
I think Youporn in one aspect is superior to other porn sites, because it doesn’t require payment, and it doesn’t result in pop-ups or spyware that usually latch on to one’s comp following visits. In that respect, it’s safer. And at least Youporn has such an obvious name that anyone who visits that site must have a requisite intention to see porn, so I don’t think that people can go there by mistake. There will be intention.
I think the main issue isn’t with porn per se. Or even with exhibitionism. The Sat edition of the ST put up some report that said that it could be illegal to upload nude pics or videos of oneself up on the internet, but I honestly think that that’s completely anal. If someone does that for you without your knowledge, it definitely constitutes an offence, but if you want to exhibit yourself on a place like Youporn where people have to knowingly click on the site to go see you, then it isn’t the same as walking around in your house naked with the windows wide open and giving your neighbours a shock of their lives.
I think the problem is probably the same one that we’ve always had – the kind of values that we want our kids to know (eep. I sound like a 50 year old. Yuck). I’m sure that most kids will at some point in their lives want to look at porn and I hear that uploading home made sex videos is now a trend for spicing up a tired sex life, but I think that if parents and educators (I’m not listing peers because peers want to do the same thing, bwahaha) are able to explain I don’t know… the value of sex? the respect that one should have for one’s own body? and things along these lines so that a 14 year old kid who enters Youporn isn’t going to get strange and funny ideas from there (although I don’t know what these ideas constitute… someone can help give me examples?), then I suppose it shouldn’t be a problem.
I think the only problem I see is if we have all these hellfire and brimstone people start taking out their pitchforks and condemning Version 2.0 the same way they did Tammy, or people trying to ascertain identity and shame the couple involved. The whole self-righteous “stoning” business is what I see as the biggest problem – people don’t take things like these rationally. But we ought to, I think.
about 4 years ago
Apparently there is a pornotube also…i thought that was closer to you tube then the you porn thingy…
about 4 years ago
i do share the same opinions as kitana.
about 4 years ago
yay! kitana is right. they think wat? youporn is not called youbaby or youfamily.
maybe next time got porn.sg
about 4 years ago
Ben,
I thought that was sammyboy?
anyway if those pitchfork wielding fellas turn out to be Christians (like the Heng fella who says old people have an OBLIGATION not to get injured) …it is up to us as rational thinking people to remind them that Jesus said ,” Let he who is not guilty of sin cast the first stone”…
about 4 years ago
Heng fella is famous lar – heck, we should interview him
but this porn not hit the fan yet
i waiting for shit to stir
btw, the said commenter tried posting the comment again…
about 4 years ago
Hello Aaron,
Keep it up! I always enjoy your blog. Happy Chinese New Year. Nice pic of you and the GF, you look very dashing.
Yours Respectfully, darkness.
about 4 years ago
Kitana,
Yes, I don’t think porn is wrong. We should not neglect the benefits of porn for couples with sagging libido.
The main point really is kids watching bizzare sex videoes without some form of guidance and starts thinking such sexual activity is normal, e.g. beastiality. This is the only thing that scares me.
about 4 years ago
Stark,
Pornotube has some barrier to entry of sorts. And the interface is not so similar. YouPorn somehow reminds me more of Youtube, esp in its early days.
about 4 years ago
darkness,
I’ve been wondering where have you been! I hope all has been well for you. Happy Chinese New Year to you too!
about 4 years ago
I don’t think young children are particularly interested in pornography, so I think these concerns about their moral safety are overblown. The first time my daughter had some weird S&M sex site pop up on her browser, she yelled for me to go and look. I told her that some people like to do that sort of thing, and although she couldn’t understand why yet, she lost interest about as quickly as she loses interest when I show her the investing site I like to check. Young children do not think about sex like adults. The young ones are simply not interested in it. And if we go on a moral crusade to “protect” them (especially the older teenagers), they’ll investigate those websites on their own, in secret.
People go nude in parks in Berlin, with families (and small children) picnicing nearby. German kids seem to get by all right. I doubt Singaporean kids are going to go insane from the (gasp) naked people on the internet either. Bring on the freedom!
about 4 years ago
kitana is right
the more u protect then more urious they get~~~~
about 4 years ago
Daniel,
The problem is that many parents can’t even talk to their children in the face about sex. They rather avoid the topic altogether. If Singaporean parents in general are able to explain sex in an unbiased and intellectual way, there would be no problem.
I agree that kids are not going to go insane from looking at naked people if they have proper guidance. There are alot of influences that parents want to protect their kids from. Why not ban them all? Let’s count what will be banned… pornography, alcohol, cigarettes…
about 4 years ago
Rin,
Speaking from personal experience?
about 4 years ago
Need a babysitter? Find the most qualified and perfect Babysitter.
Now, in addition to finding babysitter, users can find nannies, petsitters, housesitters, elder care providers, and tutors.With hundreds of thousands of care providers across the US, we make it easy to find Babysitter.
Click here to know more
about 3 years ago
Hmm. I think I am going to draw a lot of controversy/flak from saying this, but I don’t really see Youporn as a negative thing. Even though we do understand that there are no age restrictions on it, but then again, there have never been any real age restrictions on other porn sites either. A lot of people watch porn before they turn 18 or 21 anyway (although this doesn’t necessarily mean that all of them will have sex at a young age), so basically anyone who wants to watch it badly enough will find some way to, no matter what.
about 3 years ago
about 2 years ago
Hi I did not expect this load of info. This is great. Thanks!
about 1 year ago
i am a male age 40 and all this talk about kids and safe sites, we probably know 25-30 yrs ago males snuck into their dads drawers for vhs porn or playboys, internet porn is not going to corrupt the children of the world. lousy parenting, / peer pressure, wrong crowd, and vulnerable minds. that leads to kids willing to experiment in alcohol, drugs, skipping school, if not dropping out, menace to society, maybe crime and hopefully not worse. so parents, believe me if these things happen or happened internet porn???? you gonna wish thats all they were concentrating on..